This blog will feature questions (ranging from leadership and diversity to culture-specific communication, global team-building, and the nuances of business and social protocol in different countries and cultures) raised by working, adult students in higher education. You are invited to share your insights and perspectives based on your own personal work experiences. See "Welcome . . . more about this blog" for additional information about the blog's history and purpose.
Tuesday, October 20, 2015
Your thoughts . . . ?
"What are some of the most common themes in leadership theory that are prevalent across culture and history?"
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Wednesday, October 14, 2015
Leadership . . . "Personhood" in Leadership: Am I asking the right quesitons?
Now into the fourth week of a fully online graduate course,
“Foundations of Leadership,” my students and I have covered defining
leadership and examining (with an eye toward cross-cultural competence)
leadership traits, skills, culture and ethics.
Whether presenting online, classroom or hybrid courses, I find that Discussion questions are invaluable in assessing students’ ability to articulate and expand on the issues rather than just regurgitate from the text. Early in the quarter, I clearly state that I do not require students to post a specific number of contributions to the Discussion board—this is a graduate course, for goodness sake! Instead, to entice engagement, I rely on the questions being relevant to their lives, my ability to probe for deeper thinking, and the enthusiasm of fellow students conveyed in their responses. And it works. Through their reactions, ideas, and sharing of personal experiences, this exceptionally bright group of students do a great job of expanding each others' understanding of the basic theories and models of leadership as we move through the course from theory to practice.
That is, with one notable exception, which I’ll explain.
Recently, while searching for a book hidden somewhere on my unkempt bookshelves that I thought would inform a discussion on “Skills versus Process-based Approach to Leadership,” I stumbled upon Integrity by Dr. Henry Cloud. With a second cup of coffee in hand, I settled into my comfy reading chair and began exploring its pages. Before long (page 9, actually) I came across this passage:
It is one's makeup as a person, in ways much more than ethics alone, that takes people to success or enables them to sustain it if they ever achieve it. While character includes our usual understanding of ethics and integrity it is much more than that. Another way of putting it is that ethical functioning is a part of character, but not all of it. And it certainly is not all of what affects whether someone is successful or becomes a good leader.
In my own experience in over twenty years of working with CEOs, boards, managers, management teams, VPs, partners, supervisors, investors, and those who have a stake in their performance, I have seen many honest, ethical people of "integrity" who were not making it in some way. While they all were people of good "character," the reality is that their "personhood" was still preventing their talents and brains from accomplishing all that was in their potential. Some aspects to who they were as people that they had never seen as important to develop were keeping them from reaching the heights that all of the other investments they had made should have afforded them. While they met the criteria for having "integrity," they also left behind a trail of falling short in some key areas of performance that left them as well as their stakeholders and the people who depend on them wanting more. They were unable to successfully:
. Gain the complete trust of the people they were leading and capture their full hearts and following.
. See all of the realities that were right in front of them. They had blind spots regarding themselves, others, or even the markets, customers, projects, opportunities, or other external realities that kept them from reaching their goals.
. Work in a way that actually produced the outcomes that they should have produced given their abilities and resources.
. Deal with problem people, negative situations, obstacles, failures, setbacks, and losses.
. Create growth in their organization, their people, themselves, their profits, or their industry.
. Transcend their own interests and give themselves to larger purposes, thus becoming part of a larger mission.
These kinds of issues have little to do with IQ, talent, brains, education, training or most of the other important components of success. Instead, they have to do with the other aspects of character functioning that we pay way too little attention to in training people to be leaders and to be successful. The most important tool ultimately is the person and his or her makeup, and yet it seems to get the least amount of attention and work. Mostly, we focus on professional skills and knowledge instead.
Eager to share this provocative excerpt with my students and read their reactions, I posted it to the Discussion Board and added the following questions:
How, in your opinion, does Dr. Henry Cloud's thinking concur with your own? Does the excerpt expand our current discussion? If yes, how? If not, why not?
Much to my disappointment, no one responded. This no-one-came experience left me asking myself the following questions:
. Do my Discussion questions encourage students to consider the role “personhood” plays in leadership?
. Do the concepts of emotional intelligence, social intelligence, cultural intelligence, etc., truly speak to the development of “personhood”?
. Considering that leadership is an elusive term, complicated by the sheer number of leadership-related publications and the possible over-exposure of the subject, can students make meaning of the concept in their individual lives?
For me, the big takeaway was to ask myself, “Am I asking the right questions?” As an instructor, this is the question that will continue to challenge me.
Reference:
Cloud, H. (2006). Integrity: The courage to meet the demands of reality. New York, NY: Harper. ISBN: 978-0-06-084969-6
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 10/14/15
Whether presenting online, classroom or hybrid courses, I find that Discussion questions are invaluable in assessing students’ ability to articulate and expand on the issues rather than just regurgitate from the text. Early in the quarter, I clearly state that I do not require students to post a specific number of contributions to the Discussion board—this is a graduate course, for goodness sake! Instead, to entice engagement, I rely on the questions being relevant to their lives, my ability to probe for deeper thinking, and the enthusiasm of fellow students conveyed in their responses. And it works. Through their reactions, ideas, and sharing of personal experiences, this exceptionally bright group of students do a great job of expanding each others' understanding of the basic theories and models of leadership as we move through the course from theory to practice.
That is, with one notable exception, which I’ll explain.
Recently, while searching for a book hidden somewhere on my unkempt bookshelves that I thought would inform a discussion on “Skills versus Process-based Approach to Leadership,” I stumbled upon Integrity by Dr. Henry Cloud. With a second cup of coffee in hand, I settled into my comfy reading chair and began exploring its pages. Before long (page 9, actually) I came across this passage:
Who a person is will ultimately determine if their brains,
talents, competencies, energy, effort, deal-making abilities, and
opportunities will succeed
It is one's makeup as a person, in ways much more than ethics alone, that takes people to success or enables them to sustain it if they ever achieve it. While character includes our usual understanding of ethics and integrity it is much more than that. Another way of putting it is that ethical functioning is a part of character, but not all of it. And it certainly is not all of what affects whether someone is successful or becomes a good leader.
In my own experience in over twenty years of working with CEOs, boards, managers, management teams, VPs, partners, supervisors, investors, and those who have a stake in their performance, I have seen many honest, ethical people of "integrity" who were not making it in some way. While they all were people of good "character," the reality is that their "personhood" was still preventing their talents and brains from accomplishing all that was in their potential. Some aspects to who they were as people that they had never seen as important to develop were keeping them from reaching the heights that all of the other investments they had made should have afforded them. While they met the criteria for having "integrity," they also left behind a trail of falling short in some key areas of performance that left them as well as their stakeholders and the people who depend on them wanting more. They were unable to successfully:
. Gain the complete trust of the people they were leading and capture their full hearts and following.
. See all of the realities that were right in front of them. They had blind spots regarding themselves, others, or even the markets, customers, projects, opportunities, or other external realities that kept them from reaching their goals.
. Work in a way that actually produced the outcomes that they should have produced given their abilities and resources.
. Deal with problem people, negative situations, obstacles, failures, setbacks, and losses.
. Create growth in their organization, their people, themselves, their profits, or their industry.
. Transcend their own interests and give themselves to larger purposes, thus becoming part of a larger mission.
These kinds of issues have little to do with IQ, talent, brains, education, training or most of the other important components of success. Instead, they have to do with the other aspects of character functioning that we pay way too little attention to in training people to be leaders and to be successful. The most important tool ultimately is the person and his or her makeup, and yet it seems to get the least amount of attention and work. Mostly, we focus on professional skills and knowledge instead.
Eager to share this provocative excerpt with my students and read their reactions, I posted it to the Discussion Board and added the following questions:
How, in your opinion, does Dr. Henry Cloud's thinking concur with your own? Does the excerpt expand our current discussion? If yes, how? If not, why not?
Much to my disappointment, no one responded. This no-one-came experience left me asking myself the following questions:
. Do my Discussion questions encourage students to consider the role “personhood” plays in leadership?
. Do the concepts of emotional intelligence, social intelligence, cultural intelligence, etc., truly speak to the development of “personhood”?
. Considering that leadership is an elusive term, complicated by the sheer number of leadership-related publications and the possible over-exposure of the subject, can students make meaning of the concept in their individual lives?
For me, the big takeaway was to ask myself, “Am I asking the right questions?” As an instructor, this is the question that will continue to challenge me.
Reference:
Cloud, H. (2006). Integrity: The courage to meet the demands of reality. New York, NY: Harper. ISBN: 978-0-06-084969-6
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 10/14/15
Tuesday, October 6, 2015
Your thoughts . . . ?
“The biggest challenge I face in the workplace is how to effectively and graciously address language barriers in cross-cultural communication.”
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Tuesday, September 29, 2015
Your thoughts . . . ?
“I would like to understand the cultural aspect of the
country of my present residence i.e. United States. Even though I have worked
in U.S organizations, I have had very limited interactions with American
counterparts due to the nature of my job in the past. But my current job requires
me to interact with counterparts with American cultural background. I feel
understanding the cultural difference between American and Asian cultures and
how that shows up in the American corporate world- that is the most important
topic I would like to understand.”
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Tuesday, September 22, 2015
Intercultural Competence: Achieving Elements of Skill
Earlier themes in this “Intercultural Competence in the Workplace” series have addressed self-development, understanding context, connecting emotionally and assessing behavior in context. These essential connectors, through the synergy of awareness and practice, catapult one’s mindset to the level of skill—the fifth and final theme. This element is about action—applying the constituent components that inform, support and develop intercultural competence.
The model below represents the five essential themes reflected in the Intercultural Competence series. These elements respond to challenge, promote development and contribute to skill and knowledge, continually circling back, evolving and informing each other. This synergy supports and builds intercultural competence—and, at the same time, opens the way to increased learning and sensitivity.
Most skill building is specific to one’s role within an organization and—whether working domestically or abroad—hinges on organizational culture and ways in which one approaches context within the organizational setting. Ultimately, skill building is about the ability to size up whatever situation we are in and quickly assess and diffuse whatever challenges arise. For purposes of this series, skill building naturally falls into two dimensions: perspectives on intercultural skill and sources of intercultural skill building.
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 9/22/15
The model below represents the five essential themes reflected in the Intercultural Competence series. These elements respond to challenge, promote development and contribute to skill and knowledge, continually circling back, evolving and informing each other. This synergy supports and builds intercultural competence—and, at the same time, opens the way to increased learning and sensitivity.
Most skill building is specific to one’s role within an organization and—whether working domestically or abroad—hinges on organizational culture and ways in which one approaches context within the organizational setting. Ultimately, skill building is about the ability to size up whatever situation we are in and quickly assess and diffuse whatever challenges arise. For purposes of this series, skill building naturally falls into two dimensions: perspectives on intercultural skill and sources of intercultural skill building.
Perspectives on intercultural skill
Ask yourself, “How does intercultural competence inform my work?” This question will tease out the situational challenges you face related to culture in your daily interactions. An important part of intercultural skill is recognizing a situation when people are in the thick of issues and identifying ways to bring those issues to the fore. It requires creating safe space while recognizing and acknowledging feelings about difference. Skill is looking at ways to manage the difference to be more effective, as a team member or as a group. Intercultural skill is built over time, along with the ability to identify cultural nuances. Intercultural knowledge is especially necessary to maintain openness despite uncertainty in challenging cultural situations. One of the key components of intercultural competence is the ability to be present in the moment when defense reactions are triggered as a result of unknown circumstances, unknown actions, and behaviors that can’t be interpreted.Sources of skill building
Resources for building intercultural skills are readily available—models, books, workshops, in-house and online training—and strong feelings exist regarding the applicability of certain tools within the context of a workplace. In the end, however, it’s all about your mindset—how you work with and treat people. Are you culturally curious? Do you have an open mind? Are you willing to look through a lens other than your own? In his 2004 book, Presence, Peter Senge describes the moment when his own approach shifted from having to be in control to simply receiving. Since this idea of presence was introduced in 2004, the term has moved into the nomenclature of corporate environments and in popular culture in the notion of “mindfulness.” I’ll close the series with one final question: Are you “present” when dealing with intercultural challenges?Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 9/22/15
Monday, September 21, 2015
Your thoughts . . . ?
"What are some of the skills and strategies necessary to integrate as a leader in a foreign country?"
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Wednesday, September 2, 2015
Serendipity . . .
Unity in Diversity . . . Hanukkah thoughts
at the time of Rosh Hashanah
at the time of Rosh Hashanah
During a recent catch-up session with a friend of Jewish heritage over a late afternoon coffee, she mentioned the upcoming “holidays.” By the context of the conversation, I knew she was referring to a religious holiday—not the upcoming Labor Day weekend. “Which holiday is it,” I asked. “Rosh Hashanah,” she replied. Rosh Hashanah, a celebration of the Jewish new year, begins on Sunday, September 13.
My friend and I moved quickly to other topics, but later that evening while sorting through a pile of papers I found a poem given to me a few years back by another Jewish friend—an energetic and enthusiastic woman, now in her early nineties. The poem was written by her husband before he passed away almost a decade ago.
As I reread the poem—clearly written for the holiday of Hanukkah, the Jewish festival of Lights—my thoughts flashed on recent media broadcasts depicting a climate of violence, injustice, bigotry and separation. But the poet suffused his work with a passionate love of humanity—a mind’s reach for unity in diversity—and it kindled in me a light of hope.
No matter what
holiday you’ll be celebrating this month, the poem is published here
with the hope that it will touch others as it did me.
As we celebrate together in a season of light,
may we see in that light the beauty of our common humanity.
may we see in that light the beauty of our common humanity.
May we also see, reflected in that glow,
the light on our differences and the beauty of man’s diversity.
the light on our differences and the beauty of man’s diversity.
For these are the lights lit not by one man, but all men—not by one faith,
but by all faiths, not for the freedom of one—but for the freedom of all to worship,
or not to worship, each according to his belief, his heart and his conscience.
but by all faiths, not for the freedom of one—but for the freedom of all to worship,
or not to worship, each according to his belief, his heart and his conscience.
May the light that glows in that diversity illumine
the miracle and wonder of creation.
the miracle and wonder of creation.
But may we also see in the bright glare of light,
the evil of bigotry, injustice and indifference
that thrives in the darkest recesses of man’s soul.
the evil of bigotry, injustice and indifference
that thrives in the darkest recesses of man’s soul.
As we celebrate together, may we look into one another’s eyes
and see a light reflecting love, understanding and caring.
and see a light reflecting love, understanding and caring.
~ by Dr. Edward Osran ~
(Permission: Lillian Osran) I didn’t have the privilege of meeting Ed Osran—I would have appreciated knowing him.
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 9/2/15
Wednesday, August 26, 2015
Evaluating Cultural Competence in the Workplace
Are cultural needs being met in the context of your workplace?
Although establishing the presence (or absence) of intercultural
competence can be illusive, certain indicators can help in determining
whether cultural competence is present or absent. An interculturally
competent interaction might appear in one-on-one or group contexts as
relaxed dialogue; going beyond language to demonstrate a level of
comfort; no reluctance to interact; moving easily within a diverse
group; really listening; and laughing—an I’m-with-you kind of laughter.
What is it that translates cognition and attitude into culturally competent behavior? Perhaps it is the focused “seeing” that comes from internalizing three elements—cultural self-assessment, understanding context, and the ability to connect across the cultural divide—that fuse together and propel cognition and attitude into awareness and mindful behavior.
While the goal of cross-cultural communication is to impart information, it is necessary to first create a level of comfort and safety in those interactions. When intercultural competence is not present, there is an absence of real dialogue. People feel misunderstood. You can tell the difference between the brief, verbal connection that anyone can make make—one that dissipates quickly—and actual engagement in a lasting conversation.
Isn’t it incumbent upon professionals in the culturally diverse workplace to call on their skills and knowledge to assess, sense, interpret and respond to cultural needs? When culturally competent, these professionals mindfully build individual and/or group unity and trust. The result is the creation of safe space for successful cross-cultural (or difference) interaction in context—space that offers individuals and groups a non-threatening opportunity to express themselves, be themselves and disclose their issues. At this point, intercultural competence presents itself as authentic awareness.
This post led me to recall a how-do-I-know-what-I-don’t-know situation that occurred in one of my classroom sessions a few years back that emphasizes the importance of workplace awareness. Here’s the story . . .
~ A Hand Over the Heart ~
An email from a fellow instructor stated: “I have a young man from Pakistan about to graduate. He will be interviewing in U.S. American organizations and is concerned because he can't shake hands with women. I don't know what to tell him—maybe you do.”
Clearly, the young man was of Muslim faith, and devout Muslim men are not allowed to touch any woman who is not their mother, wife, children, or sisters, so I reached out to a Muslim man from my doctoral program. He responded that the young man needed to seek the counsel of his spiritual advisor. That didn't satisfy me, so I asked him what he would do in the situation. Eventually, over the course of a lengthy email exchange, he provided a solution.
At the time, I was teaching “Global Leadership: The Mindset That Matters,” and I couldn’t resist creating an exercise around this issue for my students. I divided the class in half. Group One was assigned the role of the young man from Pakistan. Group Two was given the role of a female corporate recruiter who would greet five potential hires: one female from the U.S, and one from Belgium, and three males, from the U.S., Pakistan, and France. I gave Group Two the visual prompt of the recruiter reaching her hand out to shake hands with each of the applicants, and I asked them how the greeting might unfold.
Neither group could understand why I was asking the question. Then, I read the email exchange, beginning with the request for advice from my fellow instructor. “Why should we in the U.S. need to understand this?” one student asked, with annoyance. “Hey, this guy is in the U.S., and he needs to operate by our rules,” another opined. “Religion shouldn’t be an issue in the workplace,” chimed in another student. They were uncomfortable when a culture was at odds with the one they deemed dominant in a specific context, or when it required them to know more than they thought they ought to know. It was a lively discussion pointing to the importance of awareness, particularly around religion and gender in a workplace setting. And, in case you aren’t already aware, when a devout Muslim man greets a non-Muslim woman, rather than shake hands, he places his hand over his heart and bows slightly.
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 8/26/15
What is it that translates cognition and attitude into culturally competent behavior? Perhaps it is the focused “seeing” that comes from internalizing three elements—cultural self-assessment, understanding context, and the ability to connect across the cultural divide—that fuse together and propel cognition and attitude into awareness and mindful behavior.
While the goal of cross-cultural communication is to impart information, it is necessary to first create a level of comfort and safety in those interactions. When intercultural competence is not present, there is an absence of real dialogue. People feel misunderstood. You can tell the difference between the brief, verbal connection that anyone can make make—one that dissipates quickly—and actual engagement in a lasting conversation.
Isn’t it incumbent upon professionals in the culturally diverse workplace to call on their skills and knowledge to assess, sense, interpret and respond to cultural needs? When culturally competent, these professionals mindfully build individual and/or group unity and trust. The result is the creation of safe space for successful cross-cultural (or difference) interaction in context—space that offers individuals and groups a non-threatening opportunity to express themselves, be themselves and disclose their issues. At this point, intercultural competence presents itself as authentic awareness.
This post led me to recall a how-do-I-know-what-I-don’t-know situation that occurred in one of my classroom sessions a few years back that emphasizes the importance of workplace awareness. Here’s the story . . .
~ A Hand Over the Heart ~
An email from a fellow instructor stated: “I have a young man from Pakistan about to graduate. He will be interviewing in U.S. American organizations and is concerned because he can't shake hands with women. I don't know what to tell him—maybe you do.”
Clearly, the young man was of Muslim faith, and devout Muslim men are not allowed to touch any woman who is not their mother, wife, children, or sisters, so I reached out to a Muslim man from my doctoral program. He responded that the young man needed to seek the counsel of his spiritual advisor. That didn't satisfy me, so I asked him what he would do in the situation. Eventually, over the course of a lengthy email exchange, he provided a solution.
At the time, I was teaching “Global Leadership: The Mindset That Matters,” and I couldn’t resist creating an exercise around this issue for my students. I divided the class in half. Group One was assigned the role of the young man from Pakistan. Group Two was given the role of a female corporate recruiter who would greet five potential hires: one female from the U.S, and one from Belgium, and three males, from the U.S., Pakistan, and France. I gave Group Two the visual prompt of the recruiter reaching her hand out to shake hands with each of the applicants, and I asked them how the greeting might unfold.
Neither group could understand why I was asking the question. Then, I read the email exchange, beginning with the request for advice from my fellow instructor. “Why should we in the U.S. need to understand this?” one student asked, with annoyance. “Hey, this guy is in the U.S., and he needs to operate by our rules,” another opined. “Religion shouldn’t be an issue in the workplace,” chimed in another student. They were uncomfortable when a culture was at odds with the one they deemed dominant in a specific context, or when it required them to know more than they thought they ought to know. It was a lively discussion pointing to the importance of awareness, particularly around religion and gender in a workplace setting. And, in case you aren’t already aware, when a devout Muslim man greets a non-Muslim woman, rather than shake hands, he places his hand over his heart and bows slightly.
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 8/26/15
Wednesday, August 19, 2015
Your thoughts . . . ?
"How can you best establish and maintain cultural acceptance (respect) in a global workforce?"
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Wednesday, August 12, 2015
Intercultural Competence: Reaching Across the Cultural Divide
Do intercultural skills and interpersonal skills inform each other?
This is one of the most intriguing issues in the examination of
intercultural competence. Examining the concepts of intercultural
competence versus interpersonal competence—a distinction that my
students often find unclear—is helpful in understanding and developing
intercultural competence.
What differentiates intercultural skills from interpersonal skills? It seems that intercultural competence is an expanded dimension of interpersonal competence. Thus, intercultural competence includes certain characteristics, intentions and skills that relate to cultural difference.
Think about this: When we talk about interpersonal, do we begin with the assumption that there is not much difference among individuals, but when we talk about intercultural, do we automatically assume there is significant difference and must make an effort to work effectively with difference? Does interpersonal assume we’re just trying to work effectively?
Are there additional elements to intercultural competence not included in interpersonal competence? If so, what are they? How much of intercultural skill is different from interpersonal skill? Does one need to be interpersonally competent to achieve intercultural competence? Can clear distinctions be made and, if so, what are they? How many of these competencies are trainable?
The relational aspects of both intercultural and interpersonal interaction appear to factor equally during successful cultural interaction. One element required for the development of intercultural skills that is not needed in interpersonal skill building is a great deal of knowledge about how culture shapes people's perceptions and actions. Interculturally competent people possess both intercultural and interpersonal skills and the sensitivity to work around difference and pursue their goal of cross-cultural understanding. Having the ability to synthesize, they draw on their own cultural experiences and the experiences of others to understand different perceptions of the same situation.
The relational aspects of interaction discussed here (intercultural/interpersonal) appear to factor equally into those moments during cultural interaction when emotional connection takes place.
Alan Fogel, a developmental psychologist, who speaks to this developmental process of the relational perspective in his book Developing Through Relationships: Origins of Communication, Self and Culture, claims that "communicative connections to other people are fundamental to the workings of the human mind and self.” Alfred Schultz, a social phenomenologist, describes this kind of connection as seeing “my own stream of consciousness and yours in a single, intentional act which embraces them both ... having a sense that the other person’s stream of consciousness is flowing along a track that is temporarily parallel with your own ... synchronized and interlocked.” In their book entitled Systems Theory and Family Therapy: A Primer, Becvar & Becvar interpret this connection as “... allowing for the movement to and through successive stages of growth and development.”
Framing one’s perceptual images in this way suggests people becoming interwoven, able to be in the moment. This framing focuses on interdependence.
~ The Fighting Irish—A Story of Connection ~
One of my fondest memories of my family’s exposure to cultural difference is when we hosted a teenage girl from Northern Ireland during a turbulent period in that country’s religious history. My youngest daughter served as the host sister. The program’s orientation prepared us for the realities of the religious and political strife occurring there; yet, none of us will forget watching those 12 Irish teenagers—an equal number of Catholics and Protestants—exit the customs gate at O’Hare Airport. Immediately, our young visitors grouped themselves by religious affiliation as their host families began to sort out who belonged to which family.
The month-long program involved service projects, group discussions, social events, and host-family interactions. Additionally, these bright and eager teenagers, chosen for their leadership qualities and academic accomplishments, were required to attend weekly services at the church of the religion opposite their own. The experience proved to be a successful and enriching one for all involved, so much so that a stunning image of their departure remains vivid in my mind: As they were preparing to board the plane for home, this group of young people—so obviously divided upon their arrival in the United States—were hugging each other and tearfully coming to terms with the idea that they could no longer be friends once they returned to Ireland. They were about to return to a culture that clearly impeded connection across religious differences.
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 8/12/15
What differentiates intercultural skills from interpersonal skills? It seems that intercultural competence is an expanded dimension of interpersonal competence. Thus, intercultural competence includes certain characteristics, intentions and skills that relate to cultural difference.
Think about this: When we talk about interpersonal, do we begin with the assumption that there is not much difference among individuals, but when we talk about intercultural, do we automatically assume there is significant difference and must make an effort to work effectively with difference? Does interpersonal assume we’re just trying to work effectively?
Are there additional elements to intercultural competence not included in interpersonal competence? If so, what are they? How much of intercultural skill is different from interpersonal skill? Does one need to be interpersonally competent to achieve intercultural competence? Can clear distinctions be made and, if so, what are they? How many of these competencies are trainable?
The relational aspects of both intercultural and interpersonal interaction appear to factor equally during successful cultural interaction. One element required for the development of intercultural skills that is not needed in interpersonal skill building is a great deal of knowledge about how culture shapes people's perceptions and actions. Interculturally competent people possess both intercultural and interpersonal skills and the sensitivity to work around difference and pursue their goal of cross-cultural understanding. Having the ability to synthesize, they draw on their own cultural experiences and the experiences of others to understand different perceptions of the same situation.
The relational aspects of interaction discussed here (intercultural/interpersonal) appear to factor equally into those moments during cultural interaction when emotional connection takes place.
Alan Fogel, a developmental psychologist, who speaks to this developmental process of the relational perspective in his book Developing Through Relationships: Origins of Communication, Self and Culture, claims that "communicative connections to other people are fundamental to the workings of the human mind and self.” Alfred Schultz, a social phenomenologist, describes this kind of connection as seeing “my own stream of consciousness and yours in a single, intentional act which embraces them both ... having a sense that the other person’s stream of consciousness is flowing along a track that is temporarily parallel with your own ... synchronized and interlocked.” In their book entitled Systems Theory and Family Therapy: A Primer, Becvar & Becvar interpret this connection as “... allowing for the movement to and through successive stages of growth and development.”
Framing one’s perceptual images in this way suggests people becoming interwoven, able to be in the moment. This framing focuses on interdependence.
~ The Fighting Irish—A Story of Connection ~
One of my fondest memories of my family’s exposure to cultural difference is when we hosted a teenage girl from Northern Ireland during a turbulent period in that country’s religious history. My youngest daughter served as the host sister. The program’s orientation prepared us for the realities of the religious and political strife occurring there; yet, none of us will forget watching those 12 Irish teenagers—an equal number of Catholics and Protestants—exit the customs gate at O’Hare Airport. Immediately, our young visitors grouped themselves by religious affiliation as their host families began to sort out who belonged to which family.
The month-long program involved service projects, group discussions, social events, and host-family interactions. Additionally, these bright and eager teenagers, chosen for their leadership qualities and academic accomplishments, were required to attend weekly services at the church of the religion opposite their own. The experience proved to be a successful and enriching one for all involved, so much so that a stunning image of their departure remains vivid in my mind: As they were preparing to board the plane for home, this group of young people—so obviously divided upon their arrival in the United States—were hugging each other and tearfully coming to terms with the idea that they could no longer be friends once they returned to Ireland. They were about to return to a culture that clearly impeded connection across religious differences.
Note: To comment, click "Name/URL" on the dropdown menu. Enter name or blog ID in the name field, and leave the URL field blank.
Posted on LinkedIn 8/12/15
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
